Skip to Content
January 25

Two Faces of Christian Deconstruction: Is It Always Bad?

Deconstruction can be a scary word, especially when it comes to matters of faith. Recent years have witnessed prominent figures in the Christian community abandoning their beliefs, attributing their departure to the process of “deconstructing their faith.” In this post, we explore the dual nature of deconstruction within Christianity and aim to decipher whether it serves as a helpful reset or a destructive force.

Related: How To Talk With Your Teen About Doubting God

What is Deconstruction?

To unravel the mystery surrounding deconstruction, let’s start by acknowledging the challenge of pinning down a precise definition. The term finds its roots in the 20th-century French philosopher Jacques Derrida, who advocated for scrutinizing texts to expose inconsistencies and hidden messages. In essence, deconstruction involves tearing apart a text not to gain a deeper understanding but to reveal any corrupting elements it might conceal.

Negative Connotations of Deconstruction

In the Christian realm, deconstruction has acquired a somewhat negative reputation, often portrayed as a lurking force seeking to undermine the faith of believers. Some argue that the process can be a convenient way to reject moral principles, allowing individuals to dismiss texts that challenge their beliefs as oppressive.

A Positive Perspective of Deconstruction

However, there is another side to the story. Some Christians view deconstruction as a positive endeavor, akin to stripping away non-essential elements of faith to return to its roots in Jesus and the Gospel. This perspective sees deconstruction not as a destructive force but as a means of removing weak or rotting parts to make room for a stronger, more solid foundation.

Biblical Roots of Deconstruction

Examining the Bible, we find instances of deconstruction in the Old Testament, where prophets were sent to challenge and correct the beliefs and practices of God’s people. For example, in the book of Micah, the prophet deconstructs the distorted perspective of relying on sacrifices without living justly and loving kindness.

Similarly, Jesus engaged in a form of deconstruction during his earthly ministry, challenging accepted teachings and replacing them with a truer, more holistic understanding of faith.

Reconstruction and Faith

lego blocks in the shape of a cross

The key distinction lies in the approach to deconstruction. While academic deconstruction may seek to tear down and destroy, a more Christ-like version aims to rebuild and create a stronger, Christ-filled faith. It involves the struggle to correct or deepen naive beliefs, as defined by Kirsten Sanders.

In the realm of faith, deconstruction encourages believers to reexamine their convictions, identify the core principles of their faith, and distinguish them from cultural narratives that may lead astray. Reconstruction is emphasized as an equally important process, urging believers to replace the weakened parts of their faith with something stronger, truer, and more aligned with Christ’s teachings.

Tim Keller’s wisdom reminds us that Christians must rethink their faith while simultaneously “doubting their doubts” and challenging cultural narratives that oppose Christian beliefs.

The Bottom Line

The journey of deconstruction within faith is a nuanced one. It involves tearing down misconceptions, challenging cultural narratives, and rebuilding a faith that is strong, true, and Christ-honoring. The process, when approached with a sincere desire for truth, can lead to a deeper and more authentic connection with one’s faith.

As you reflect on the role of deconstruction in your own faith journey, consider the following questions:

1) Do you perceive deconstruction as a positive or negative force in the context of faith? Why?

2) What, in your view, are the essential elements of the Christian faith that should be preserved amidst the process of deconstruction and reconstruction?

The Culture Translator

A weekly email to help you stay up to date on the music, movies, TV shows, and social media trends impacting your kid’s world.